Skip to content

Study shows lower lifetime earning for pandemic-era students

'We need more effective teachers,' says Eric Hanushek of Stanford's Hoover Institution
Teacher Monica Gutierrez reads to her second grade students at Los Robles-Ronald McNair Academy in East Palo Alto on Aug. 26, 2022.

Students nationwide face lower earnings over their lifetime because of a loss of education during the pandemic, a Stanford economist said in a recently completed study, adding that the loss will be even greater for California students.

The average student across the U.S. will lose $70,000 in earnings over their lifetime if something isn't done to offset the learning loss.

California students may lose more than $70,000 in lifetime earnings because earnings overall are higher in California than in many other states.

Economist Eric Hanushek at Stanford's Hoover Institution said to offset the loss "we need more effective teachers."

Hanushek is an international expert in the economic analysis of educational issues.

He said the quality of learning is more important than the quantity of learning when it comes to offsetting the loss. Quality depends on the effectiveness of teachers, he said.

To improve learning quality, he said, schools can provide incentives to its best teachers.

"You provide incentives to your better teachers to take on more kids," Hanushek said in an interview Thursday.

Schools systems now have a lot of federal money available to them and that money could be used to provide the incentives, Hanushek said. The money could also be used to buy out the contracts of the least effective teachers, he said.

Schools have tried to promote additional or longer school days to make up for learning losses. Hanushek said that may not be effective.

Hanushek estimated the loss in each state's gross domestic product over the rest of the 21st century due to what may be a lower-skilled workforce.

GDP is expected to be about 1.4% lower each year in California over the rest of the century than it would be if the learning loss did not occur, according to the study. In dollar terms, the loss comes to $1.3 trillion through 2099.

Hanushek calculated that amount by adding up the losses each year and reducing the future ones. The future ones were reduced by an amount to account for their uncertainly and because losses in the future are not as painful as present ones.

California's gross domestic product was about $3.37 trillion in 2021, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

"These losses are permanent unless a state's schools can get better than their pre-pandemic levels," Hanushek wrote in the study.

The immediate impact on California and other state's economies will begin to be felt when current students finish school and become a substantial part of the labor force, the study said.

Because it will not be felt for years, people may ignore the impact.

"That is a mistake, because the economic impact is truly significant," Hanushek wrote.

The study also said that disadvantaged children suffered greater losses in learning than other children and therefore may suffer greater losses in earnings.

push icon
Be the first to read breaking stories. Enable push notifications on your device. Disable anytime.
No thanks